Customer Reviews for Murdick Auto Parts
(U-Haul Neighborhood Dealer)

357 reviews

576 Evans City Rd   Butler, PA 16001
(Rt 68 & Whitestown Rd)

(724) 482-4484

Office Hours

  • Mon-Thur: 10 am–6 pm
  • Fri-Sat: 10 am–5 pm
  • Sun: Closed

Services at this Location:

Contact Us

(724) 482-4484

576 Evans City Rd
Butler, PA 16001
(Rt 68 & Whitestown Rd)

Services at this Location:

Office Hours

  • Mon-Thur: 10 am–6 pm
  • Fri-Sat: 10 am–5 pm
  • Sun: Closed
  • Free towing inspection
  • 24 hour customer return

Testimonials From Recent Customers

Customer feedback is extremely important to us. We use these reviews to guide our efforts and improve our service. Everything that follows is direct from our customers, without any filtering or editing on our part.

Overall Rating:

Reviews without text are currently hidden. Show them shown. Hide them

Rating:
3.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

bob kalisek 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

cindy palladino 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Pat Newbern 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Pat Newbern 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Anthony Bilott 
Rating:
3.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Greg Fowler 
Rating:
5.0

Owner was very kind, respectful, and friendly. A very nice guy to deal with and answered all my questions!

chad fabian 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

ALAN WILKINSON 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Steven Hottenfeller 
Rating:
5.0

Nothing everything was great!! This guy is so kind, we need more business owners like him.

MELLISA PHILLIPS 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

eric Porter 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

rachael hinch 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Pat Newbern 
Rating:
2.0

This was the worst experience I have ever had! Your app is definitely not user friendly at all! I rented a van for 6 hours and I wasted 1hr between picking up and returning that I paid for! Worst yet is that I was overcharged and doubled charged and had to spend another hour with two different CSR’s and my account was still not reimbursed correctly! Terrible experience!!

Helen Jurysta 
Rating:
1.0

Location was not bad however the renting process was terrible. Never again. Was a headache from the beginning. You can not do nothing until you get to the location, which was pouring down rain stuck outside asking me questions that I already answered previous to arrival. Then after re filling out everything they needed to approve my rental and call a friend ? While I’m standing in the rain ! Then on top of that needed an extra 100$ that they said nothing about so after all of that I had to go put more money in my account and come back to do it again. Then when dropping off the drop off page wouldn’t load. Never again!!!

Marki Seezox 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Pat Newbern 
Rating:
5.0

Truck was parked in a spot that was tight & tough to get out of. Perhaps truck could have been parked in a spot making it easier for the customer to leave from.

David Fuhrman 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Jason Voyda 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Robin Moretti 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Jerome Zufelt 
Rating:
2.0

I just received an additional cost from my rental with NO explanation for the charge. Rental by app sucked, return sucked with all the BS and now I want to know why it cost over $126 to rent a truck for 3.5 hours. WTF was the additional charge for? This was supposedly to be an easy way to do this yet it took longer and cost more.

Patrick Murphy 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Andrew Miller 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Pat Newbern 
Rating:
5.0

The trailer that I originally wanted hadn't been returned yet and Mr Murdick offered to come back in the evening once it was returned so that I could get it. I ended up taking a different one, but really appreciated his offer.

Donald Uber 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Kelly Jerome 
Rating:
3.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Patience Hamilton 
Rating:
4.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Lawrence Seibel 
Rating:
5.0

This is a convenient location and it’s easy to get in and out of. Quick in and out! Keep up the great work!

clifford morin 
Rating:
5.0

Murdick's has been around a long time. I've dealt with them numerous times and keep going back. The moving company I contracted through the UHaul website however, is another matter. Move My Stuff, LLC NEVER showed up. Never called, nothing. I tried to contact them and the number I had for them is no longer in service.

Robert Mick 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

David Myers 
Rating:
3.0

Used my phone to return the 26' truck. Never interacted with anyone but the return lot was small and difficult to maneuver this size truck to park it and walk around to get good photos. Very tight parking but very convenient location for me for my drop off.

Kathy Stephan 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Willard Burns 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Ronald Wolfe 
Rating:
3.0

N/A

Eleni Hallas 
Rating:
2.0

The past few times we have rented we never get the proper codes to get keys! We spent OVER an hour on the phone and had to call twice before we were able to leave. This seems to be a common practice and really a deterrent from renting again.

ROBERT THOMPSON 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

marsha clark 
Rating:
1.0

I don't think it was the gentleman's fault but my experience was not good. I was suppose to get the van at 10:00, I did not walk out of there until 11:00. It was very inconvenient for everyone involved. Internet issues and whatnot.

jeffrey carson 
Rating:
4.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Seventy Solutions 
Rating:
2.0

We planned with Murdick’s to pick up the Uhaul at 10am when the store opened on a Saturday. The owner of the store was in Florida and he said other relatives would be operating the store while he was away. No one was there to open the store. We had to personally call the owner in Florida a few times to try to check in. The people who were operating the store while the owner was away finally came around 10:35am. The Uhaul website was not working for the owner who was trying to check us in remotely. We tried to return the Uhaul during store business hours, but the people who were supposed to be operating the store were not there again. We tried returning the Uhaul through the Uhaul website which seemed like it was supposed to be very simple, but the website wasn’t working. We had a very frustrating experience overall but thankfully the owner did help us over the phone from Florida.

Andrew Kudamik 
Rating:
5.0

Love working with Murdicks for my U-haul and auto part needs! Wonderful gentlemen to work with

David Camus 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Marangely Soler 
Rating:
5.0

Rented several times there and always positive experiences. I will be needing to rent again soon and will go to this location.

ronald wolfe 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

MICHAEL BARNES 
Rating:
4.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

KEVIN SMITH 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Teresa Benson 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

PAtricia Hirt 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

larry lutheran 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Sebastian Fundark 
Rating:
3.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Thomas Sheridan 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

David Bixler 
Rating:
5.0

Have received excellent service at this location. This was the 3rd rental in the past 2 months. There were no trucks available and one showed up at the last minute that we were able to secure. It worked perfectly.

Brian Platt 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

JEANNINE GOELZ 
Rating:
2.0

It’s not the location so much as the U-Haul reservation system. I reserved a pickup at one location. When I showed up I found out the reservation had changed to this location and to a larger vehicle. I also had to wait for about 15-20 minutes for other customers to be taken care of. Also after I got the final bill I found out I had been charged for Safe Move even though I did not select that service. I then had to spend time waiting for a chat agent to get the fee refunded. Not certain I’ll rent from you again.

Greg Cioffi 
Rating:
2.0

Owners arrived 15 minutes late to open store. I had a a 10:00 AM rental and didn’t get on the road until 10:30, I even preregister. This cost me about a hour of waiting time at a store. No apology to myself or two other customers waiting.

Scott Mason 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Edward Schiebel 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Jeff Cettin 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Ronald Mahan 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Cameron Daugherty 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Kevin Neubert 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Brenda Evans 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Mary Squeglia 
Rating:
3.0

Include all prices. Be upfront.

Jonathan Wozny 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Joanne Wissinger 
Rating:
4.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

George Brown 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

THOMAS ERNST 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Todd Montgomery 
Rating:
3.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

JAMES BURGER 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

CINDY WILLIAMS 
Rating:
4.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Zachary Porter 
Rating:
5.0

Very good service but I do not like the 24/7 share. I'd rather check in live which I kinda did!

kim sechrist 
Rating:
4.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

BRETT BLASKOWITZ 
Rating:
3.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Edwin Koch 
Rating:
2.0

This location never has anyone there to do the actual uhaul stuff. They did have the only uhaul available in the entire county but they were closed when we picked it up and had to use the AWFUL uhaul app to check in. The trick sounded like it was going to blow the transmission the entire time and had almost 100k miles on it. When I contacted uhaul customer support, they wanted me to file a claim and wait for someone to come and deem out "save." I only had it for 6 hours, and it took almost 45 minutes to check out in. I opted out of roadside assistance, used it to move, and then when I tried to return it, the place was closed so I had to use the uhaul app again to return it. In the pouring rain and unlit parking lot, the app wouldn't let me do the check in process even though I tried on two different phones. It took 45 minutes of trying to return until I dropped the keys in the drop box, called the customer service line and was told there was a 63 minute wait. At 9pm on a Sunday. They called me back an hour later and then promptly hung up on me 25 seconds into the call. No contact again from them. Then received a bill in an email at like 11am this morning. What an absolute nightmare. The uhaul app is completely unusable. Overhaul it or get more people to answer the phone. Never again.

Natalie Morin 
Rating:
4.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Richard Davis 
Rating:
4.0

Helpful with getting charge for insurance I did not want remove when my reservation location was changed. I did not appreciate the reservation changed to a location 25 miles further away than my original reservation.

Michael Eisenfeld 
Rating:
1.0

Owner showed up 20 minutes late to open and wasn’t prepared for my rental. The store is a mess and was very unprofessional.

James Smith 
Rating:
1.0

horror. promised $ 480. from Pennsylvania to Florida we drove for a day. and they removed 2400 from the account. did not send a check

Shark Luvin 
Rating:
3.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

jack hollibaugh 
Rating:
1.0

Nobody would return my calls or pick up a phone after more than 30 minutes on hold. This is not about location but your equipment. It has been all day and it still is not resolved. I want a full refund for putting my family in danger. Mechanic came by and said it’s not tranny fluid and the truck should have NEVER left FL let alone a 900 mile trip.

WILLIAM STCLAIR 
Rating:
1.0

Hardly any fuel, transmission wasn't working properly, ceiling was falling out of cab, strap on dolly was already broken and the online check in and drop off was a joke. Will definitely not use again. Never had trouble with Penske.

MELVIN BAGLEY 
Rating:
4.0

Front brakes on van we’re terrible, the steering wheel shook every time the brakes were applied

Kenneth Douglass 
Rating:
2.0

Door wouldn't open and close easy. Tires are worn. Had a blowout on the trip.

DINA WILLIAMS 
Rating:
3.0

when picking up, the gentleman was at the counter, no others in the store, but he was obviously inputting something in to the computer. he let me stand there for more than 5 minutes without even acknowledging me. a simple just a minute or I'll be with you, would have been nice. it would not stop me from renting there again, but customer service is important.

BethAnn Hinton 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Darin Corey 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Robin Collins 
Rating:
3.0

The back of the uhaul was very muddy and we had to clean it before we used it. The man was also very rude when I asked about returning to another location

Melissa Geist 
Rating:
3.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

RICHARD FREELAND 
Rating:
1.0

He was 10 minutes late, the computer was down, he answered the phone and talked car parts while there was a line waiting. One person left. I'll rent a truck somewhere else next time.

Joseph Genova 
Rating:
5.0

Very convenient to drop off.

RYANSCOTT GILLON 
Rating:
5.0

The service was good , very nice lady . Store is a bit disorganized

CHASE RODGERS 
Rating:
3.0

This is not a full time franchise. It is operated out of a Auto Parts Store where the owner goes to Florida during the winter. He is answering the phone during the day to set up appointments with his daughter and son-in-law which are made at their convenience. I asked for 5 pm the day before the pickup only to arrive at the location and find nobody around. The owner tried to get the pickup scheduled for 6 the day that I called but did agree to 5. I tried to call the listed phone number only to find the mailbox full. That left me to call U-Haul Corporate where the agent was able to make contact with the owner. Finally at 6:00 pm, they showed up to get me hooked up and do the paperwork. The 4-pin pigtail was crushed at two places showing bare conductor. The agent was able to find a replacement and did get it fixed. I was given personal phone numbers to contact for the return which went well. The problem that I have is that they are operating the franchise when it is convenient for them. If the location is not manned, they need signage indicating alternate phone numbers to contact. There was another customer waiting in the parking lot when I got there, trying to rent a truck by signing online from their smart phones. They finally gave up and left. The only reason that I found out what goes on with the business is that I went to the Pizza Shop next door to try and find out what goes on there.

FRED TURNER 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

JAMES BURGER 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

William Linton 
Rating:
2.0

This was the second time I used Murdick to pick up a truck. First time was great, this time took a halhour due to some computer problems in the signout process. I can't say for sure if it was the facility's fault. The truck had food wrappers and chips crumbs in the cab, wasn't shoveled out of the snow well, and had a big scratch on the side that I wasn't informed of, then of course worried that I would be blamed. The fuel gauge upon pick up also barely touched the F line, which meant it was several gallons down when I got it.

Joseph Sunder 
Rating:
3.0

Old School Charm

Andrew Connell 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Harold Moon 
Rating:
4.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Andrew Muisiner 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Joanne Roman 
Rating:
2.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Donald Mahoney 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Fred Thomas 
No reviews have been submitted for this location.

Additional Services at this Location

  • Moving Trucks

    We have the largest selection of new trucks!

  • Trailers & Towing

    Our cargo and utility trailers start at $14.95!

  • Moving Supplies

    We sell hundreds of products to make moving easier!

Back
To Top